Same Sex Marriage Should Not Be Legal Essay

Same Sex Marriage Should Not Be Legal Essay-64
As a sociological reality, this criticism is hard to dispute.But as an argument against same-sex marriage it rests on a false choice.

We can realize that a law that once seemed well designed could, in fact, be fairer.

Reexamining marriage laws with this possibility in mind, we should register the following facts.

According to the other, it is simply absurd to believe that considerations of equal treatment favor recognizing same-sex marriages. Civil marriage was instituted, let us concede, to safeguard the interests of children by endorsing and protecting the kind of stable, committed relationships that produce them and are suited to their upbringing.

But there is no way to know in advance which couples can or will have children; we would hardly want county clerks to administer fertility tests or ask intrusive questions about people’s ability or intention to reproduce.

They say that doing so will enshrine the idea that marriage is about the fulfillment of adults rather than the interests of children.

This slogan is of a piece with their broader criticism of the sexual revolution, which they say has harmed children by encouraging adults to seek romantic fulfillment even when it conflicts with their responsibilities as parents.he debate about same-sex marriage often seems limited to two points of view.According to one, opposing the judicial invalidation of traditional marriage laws is tantamount to supporting segregationist racism.But even if they have no children, we can understand perfectly well why they would choose to make a vow of permanent and exclusive commitment.The intelligibility of this choice is all we need to justify their inclusion.It would suppress the reality that committed romantic relationships Another way of saying this is that sexual counter-revolutionaries are telling a noble lie.The lie is that it is immoral to think of sex and marriage as anything other than child-directed, and its motivation is that, if we allow people to think otherwise, some parents will falsely analogize their own situation to that of people who have no children.The noble lie thus forecloses a piece of irrationality on the part of the public (which is always the justification of noble lies).The trouble with noble lies is that sooner or later people see through them.It may also be true, as traditionalists argue, that we would never have designed an institution from scratch solely to protect a certain category of amorous relationship.But neither did we have to safeguard the interests of children by protecting a certain category of amorous relationship.


Comments Same Sex Marriage Should Not Be Legal Essay

  • Why same sex marriage should be legal essay - Approved.

    Feb 3, 2016. Why same sex marriage should be legal essay - Only HQ writing services. jonathan soroff explains why the case against gay is not be legal?…

  • An Equal Chance at Love Why We Should Recognize Same.

    May 19, 2015. The debate about same-sex marriage often seems limited to two. We can realize that a law that once seemed well designed could. What traditionalists must in honesty be said to reject is, if not a deep. Photo Essays.…

  • Equality and Justice for Lesbian and Gay Families and.

    Intended protection against sudden eviction should not rest on fictitious legal distinctions or genetic history, but instead should find its foundation in the. iconic Paula Ettelbrick and Tom Stoddard essays.5 The case provides one lens for. See Thomas Stoddard, Why Gay People Should Seek the Right to Marry. OUT/LOOK.…

  • Should Gay Marriage Be Legalized? Publish your master's.

    Spiritual matters and conservative ideas may oppose the legalization of gay marriage, what is. For the first argument, gay marriage should be legalized because gays have the rights to exercise and. An essay concerning the libertarian.…

  • History of same-sex marriage in the United States - Wikipedia

    The history of same-sex marriage in the United States dates from the early 1970s, when the first. The first legal same-sex marriage ceremony in the United States happened on February 12th, 2004, when the. The Democratic National Convention adopted a platform that "opposesthe Defense of Marriage Act and all.…

  • Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Issues in Philosophy

    Regarding same- sex marriage are the occasion of this collection of essays. reason” to oppose treating same-sex unions as marriages is irregularly shaped.…

  • Same-sex marriage Why people really oppose it - USA Today

    Mar 2, 2015. Why do you oppose same-sex marriage? Indiana University sociologist Brian Powell posed this question to hundreds of people across the.…

  • Gay Marriage Essay Examples Kibin

    Browse essays about Gay Marriage and find inspiration. Learn by. There have been many legal debates concerning. Others feel that gay marriage should not be legalized but civil unions should be granted to homosexuals so they.…

The Latest from ©